"Building People"

The Sign

On my daily commute to and from work I pass a Protestant church, not an especially large one, that has a new sign. You know the type of sign. It's one of those signs where, using letters, you can put up changing messages or announcements. We have a similar one at St. Mary's. It's a nifty type of sign to have and very useful. The nice thing about signs like this is that you can invite the general public in to various events, place a message, or do whatever and the message is actually readable since the letters are fairly large. It also relays to the general public the vitality of a congregation.

I of course have no particular bone to pick with this church. In fact, a good friend of mine (now a Catholic "revert,") used to be a member of this church. There are also a couple of kids where I work who have told me they are members of this church. All are very nice people.

Anyway, being a religion nerd I always make a point of reading signs like this. The message they have up right now struck me immediately when they first put it up about two weeks ago. But no matter how much I've thought about it I've been unclear about the point that they are making. My first impulse was that it might be a direct response to the crisis in the Diocese of Camden, since so many other evangelical churches seem to be reaching out to the many Catholics in our region jaded by the havoc currently being wreaked by the bishop. But of course I have no way of knowing this, and probably it's not the case.

As you can see from the picture, the sign says this:

IMG_5651
Our church/Not a building/But building people

In A Way, They're Right

Certainly they are right in the sense that a church is not merely a structure. We read in 1Peter that we are to be living stones:

Be you also as living stones built up, a spiritual house, a holy priesthood, to offer up spiritual sacrifices, acceptable to God by Jesus Christ.

If we are really Christians, we should be transformed in Christ. In Ephesians 4 we read that we should

put off, according to former conversation, the old man, who is corrupted according to the desire of error. And be renewed in the spirit of your mind: And put on the new man, who according to God is created in justice and holiness of truth.

In this sense, any church that truly has Christ as its center and any Christian who truly loves God should be "changed" by Him, we should be continually changing people. Of course, it cannot be understated that the Truth that is the Church does not change. We are to be changed by It. We should allow Christ to change us so that we become more closely conformed to Him. Arguably, this is our single greatest goal and challenge as Christians: to be less focused on ourselves and more focused on Him. It's really pretty simple.

Worldly Religion

And yet there's a problem here. I think the reason why the message on this sign has stuck in my mind is the potential implications. One, there is an implication that "building people" is a central objective of the church. In our individualistic day and age, this message is a gratifying one. This is, of course, not surprising. It is the reason why increasing numbers of people are willing to identify themselves not as "religious" but "spiritual."

The impetus for such a sign, wittingly or unwittingly, would be to relay the message that one can both be religious and still be "me-centered."* Is this the right message to send about your church? Not in my opinion. But it is, at least in part, a reason why so many evangelical and non-denominational-style churches are so successful in attracting people. They have a "come as you are" (and often a "stay as you are") message.

CAYA.jpg
"CAYA" stands for "Come As You Are." The Scripture verses they cite say sort of the opposite--
that if you are willing to take His yoke he will refresh you. (From this Ohio church)

St. Paul tells us both in Romans and in Galatians to "put ye on the Lord Jesus Christ." We are no longer ourselves, but are to die to ourselves. In Romans and Colossions St. Paul tells us that we are buried with Christ in baptism:

Know you not that all we, who are baptized in Christ Jesus, are baptized in his death? For we are buried together with him by baptism unto death; that as Christ is risen from the dead by the glory of the Father, so we also may walk in newness of life.

Dr. Jesus, PsyD

Two, the connotation here is that treating religious practice as therapeutic exercise is not only acceptable, but is an actual function of the church.
I'm sure many of you have witnessed the horrendous consequences of me-centered, therapeutic religion. Again, the focus here is wrong. If we "stay close to Jesus," as Sr. Regina used to say back in high school, then He can heal us. But we will never be healed if the focus of our religious practice is ourselves. In this case, we are not worshiping God at all, but instead worshiping ourselves, and that is idolatry. It can be argued that idolatry is the particular sin of our society today, and as Christians we are to come out from the world (2Corinthians 6:17, John 15: 18-20).

Cappuccino Christianity

In a nutshell, this is the problem we are facing here in the Diocese of Camden. What we are confronting, what is being foisted upon us by our current bishop and his administration, is a worldly sort of Christianity, if it can even be called that.

Don't get me wrong: there is nothing wrong with wanting to be changed in Christ. It's just that individualistic religion is not and should not be a feature of Christianity. And don't get me wrong: there's nothing inherently wrong with wanting to socialize with people from your church. Not at all. It's just that having fun and gaining a social life should not be the motivation for going to church, nor should it be something we use as bait.



Above: Is it a mall? Is it a church? Is it a children's playland? Is it a movie theater?
The new era of entertainment-style worship, complete with music, computers, food &
drink, and giant slides.
See also: Gigantic community center type church in Kalamazoo:
"Kids come to this church, we've got slides." Truly scary people. It's sad people give their
hard earned money to these...people in the name of God.

Catholic vs. Contemporary Protestant Views of Church

There is an excellent article in the Catholic Encyclopedia on the Church (ecclesia) in which both Catholic and the prevalent protestant views of the church are aptly summarized. The Catholic Church has always taught that the Church is a visible entity. It is a divine society, begun by Christ Jesus and with its origin in the apostles, it is a necessary means of our salvation, it is authoritative. It is one, holy, Catholic, and apostolic. It is, though, visible.

By contrast, a popular protestant position today is that the church is an "ideal invisible church, a mystical communion" of believers. But what kind of God would have done this to His faithful? It is fair to say, from a "common sense" rather than a heady theological perspective, that Jesus would not have left us with a splintered Church, the true faithful found scattered among the thousands of congregations and denominations, only visible to the eyes of God. After all, how then would we know where to turn? Whose authority ought we trust?

Knowing He would ultimately suffer and die for our sakes, wouldn't He have left someone in charge here on earth? Doesn't it make sense that, in His great mercy and love for us, He would have left Himself in the Eucharist? And as churches (parishes) would become established, wouldn't it make sense that He would desire His holy Presence to be preserved in these special places, where His children could commune with Him? 

We Know Him Through Our Churches

Yes, He promised us in John 14:18 that "I will not leave you orphans, I will come to you." This promise He has kept for more than two thousand years. In the synoptic Gospels He gives us His Body and Blood, true and actual Food for our souls, not metaphorical food. And He promises us in Matthew 28:20"behold I am with you all days, even to the consummation of the world." He has given us Himself in the Eucharist, and the Eucharist is preserved in all true Catholic churches.

In that He has promised to be with us actually, corporeally, in the Holy Eucharist, in and with His Holy Church (and indeed individual parishes), he has drawn us together as one Body of Christians, not  as distinct individuals who happen to worship at the same time in the same place, but as his Mystical Bride. Though the Church itself is "not a building," as the diocesan administration is so fond of saying, the true Presence of Christ is preserved in these sacred places. And the Church itself is the Mystical yet nonetheless visible Bride of Christ.

How different a conception that is than "building people." As Christians we ought not be in the "people building" business, but in the business of glorifying God for His sake, and love of neighbor flows from that. Out of obedience to the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, we need to dwell in unity and truth. The importance of the doctrine of the visibility of the Church and even of our church buildings should not be underestimated!

Therefore let it be known: Our churches are, in fact not just buildings! We as the Body of Christ, the Church Militant, with the grace of God have built them and they are our parishes, our spiritual homes, in which the Real Presence of Jesus Christ is known, loved, worshiped, and experienced. They are Communities of the Faithful, within which we are a changed people, and they are not dispensable!

Wherefore putting away lying, speak; ye the truth every man with his neighbour; for we are members one of another. (Ephesians 4:25)


Notes:
* This is also the reason why so many new "Catholic hymns" such as "On Eagle's Wings" are so popular. A priest I know refers to this as the loathed "You Who Song." And certainly this is not the worst of them, but it is the one that comes immediately to mind. Consider the self-soothing lyrics (by Michael Joncas--in their entirety here). I have put in bold all the "self" references:

You who dwell in the shelter of the Lord
Who abide in His shadow for life,
Say to the Lord, "My Refuge,
My Rock in Whom I trust."

And He will raise you up on eagle's wings
Bear you on the breath of dawn
Make you to shine like the sun
And hold you in the palm of His hand.

While the song is about trusting God, it's mostly about all the great things that God can do for you, and not so much about the glory due our Savior and Creator, His mercy, His suffering, or much else. The song mainly treats God as a bastion, but not a firm one. A squishy one. He'll make you feel better, will protect you from danger, and make you great. Kind of a cross between a teddy bear, a , a fortress, and a super hero, I guess.

Support the Campaign!

Why Save St. Mary's?

What's true for OL Queen of Peace, Pitman & Assumption, Wildwood Crest is also true for St. Mary's Malaga:

"The people in Pitman bought that ground and built that church and it belongs to them. You can't just take it away."

-Anthony Mecca, Queen of Peace Parish, Pitman (also on the slate for closure), May 8, 2008

"This is God's house. Let us live here with God as we've done all these years."

-Fred Spiewak, Assumption Parish, Wildwood Crest, June 11, 2008

Frequently Asked Questions

Full list of Frequently Asked Questions about the Church Closings

Recent Entries

Short video of beginning of procession
Our Lady is removed from the altar and carefully placed on the handmade barque. See also our Youtube channel here:…
Some Pictures from the Feast
We hope top have a few more pictures for you soon. The church was absolutely packed during Mass and the…
We Made the Phila Inquirer!
Certainly not the first time we've made it into a major newspaper. God smiles on us."Carnival Draws a Crowd in…

Email Signup

Sign up for daily email updates about the campaign.

Enter your email address:

Facebook

Twitter: Savestmarys

Confidential Tip Line

We would like to announce our totally confidential tip line, for anyone with information pertaining to St. Mary's or their own parish, dealings with the diocese, etc. Remember, you need not give your name, or you may if you choose to. Contact us by email: info@savestmarys.net or phone: 856-692-0222 (ask for Leah).