Shifty Shifting Demographics - Revised

Bishop Galante's parish reconfiguration plan, if implemented, will result in a reduction of parishes in the Diocese of Camden from 125 to 68 (a 46% reduction) and a reduction of churches from 133 to approximately 103 (a 22% reduction).  One of the four justifications offered by Bishop for the parish reconfiguration was "shifting demographics."   The following is an excerpt from Bishop's reconfiguration announcement:

 

"Second, in many areas of the diocese, parish facilities exist in very close geographic proximity to each other.  They were established in a different era to serve Catholic people that have now moved from former Catholic population centers into other parts of South Jersey or even out of the diocese completely, leaving behind under-utilized and often aging facilities." 

 

A quick summary of population data for some areas of the diocese are shown below (all from wikipedia):

 

                    Deptford           Salem County                Camden                   Atlantic City

1950                 7,304                 49,508                       124,555                       61,657

1960               17,878                 58,711                       117,159                       59,544

2006-7*          30,529                 66,595                         80,010                      39,684

*most recent available estimate

So, here are some logical conclusions based on these demographics and Bishop's statement above.  Deptford, which has more than quadrupled in size since 1950, and Salem County, which has seen slow steady growth and is one of the few areas left in NJ that is not already built out, should see very little impact from the reconfiguration.  On the other hand, Camden and AC, which have lost more than one-third of their population will likely suffer a high percentage loss of churches and parishes.  This all seems pretty basic and straightforward, so let's see if the high paid diocesan consultants came to the same conclusion.   (We're not going to bother pretending that anyone else had any input into the decisions). 

 Let's look at Salem County first.  Salem County started with six parishes and six churches.  After the reconfiguration, only one of the six Salem County parishes will remain, with three churches.  This is an 83% reduction in parishes (compared to 46% throughout the diocese) and a 50% reduction in churches (compared to 22% throughout the diocese).  That's odd.  Did those high price consultants (paid for by YOUR DONATIONS) somehow conclude that rural Salem County is suffering an extreme Catholic exodus?  Perhaps the result of urban decay, loss of industry, gangs and crime?  Do they actually think that Salem County's six parishes (the fewest of any county in NJ) are somehow "in very close geographic proximity to each other," thereby justifying their closures?  Could it be that they believe the small churches in Salem County are actually huge, empty "facilities" falling into disrepair?  Have they ever even been to Salem County?  For that matter, has the Bishop?  Is this what they would expect us to believe about Salem County?

06-07 164
Two more Catholics leave Salem County. They walk past former luxury apartments, now in a state of decay and infested by cows...

19
A member of the notorious 0719 gang watches...

Compare this to the way Camden and Atlantic City fared in the reconfiguration process.  Camden began the parish reconfiguration process with nine parishes and nine churches.  After the reconfiguration, Camden will have six parishes and eight churches.  So there will be a 33% reduction in parishes (compared to 46% throughout the diocese and 83% in Salem County) and an 11% reduction in churches (compared to 22% throughout the diocese and 50% in Salem County).  Wow - those consultants must have concluded that Camden has NOT suffered from shifting demographics, while the rest of the diocese has.

 

Similarly, Atlantic City started the process with five parishes and five churches.  Oddly, Bishop actually lists a sixth parish, Holy Spirit, saying he intends to "merge Our Lady Star of the Sea (Atlantic City) and Holy Spirit (Atlantic City) at Our Lady Star of the Sea."  But since Holy Spirit Parish does not actually exist, I am not going to count it.  After the reconfiguration, Atlantic City will have, stunningly, five parishes and five churches, a 0% reduction in each.  Is Atlantic City a model of Catholic vibrancy or what?  Who are these consultants?  Follieri and company?  Someone else as equally "qualified?"   

 

Apparently they must have concluded that the plight of urban decay, with Catholics fleeing rust belt cities, has affected areas of the diocese like Waterford, Blue Anchor, and Malaga.  Have they ever heard of the Pine Barrens, Pineys, the Jersey Devil?  Have they ever seen a cranberry bog?  But, perhaps most distressing of all is that they seem to believe that ALL Catholics have left the apparent aging metropolis of Deptford Township, as evidenced by the fact that after the reconfiguration it will have zero Catholic churches.  That's right - no Catholic presence in Deptford. 

You gotta love consultants (no offense intended Bob).  It seems that the area that more than quadrupled in size (Deptford) will lose all of its parishes and churches.  The area that had steady growth (Salem County) will lose the majority of its parishes and churches and the two areas (Camden and AC) which lost more than 1/3 of their population will be almost completely unaffected.  Oops - guess it must have been "backwards day" at the Chancery when this plan was hatched! 

(By the way, I'm not suggesting that churches in Camden or Atlantic City should close; rather, I am simply pointing out that the justifications for the churches that are closing are completely bogus.)

Support the Campaign!

Why Save St. Mary's?

What's true for OL Queen of Peace, Pitman & Assumption, Wildwood Crest is also true for St. Mary's Malaga:

"The people in Pitman bought that ground and built that church and it belongs to them. You can't just take it away."

-Anthony Mecca, Queen of Peace Parish, Pitman (also on the slate for closure), May 8, 2008

"This is God's house. Let us live here with God as we've done all these years."

-Fred Spiewak, Assumption Parish, Wildwood Crest, June 11, 2008

Frequently Asked Questions

Full list of Frequently Asked Questions about the Church Closings

Recent Entries

Short video of beginning of procession
Our Lady is removed from the altar and carefully placed on the handmade barque. See also our Youtube channel here:…
Some Pictures from the Feast
We hope top have a few more pictures for you soon. The church was absolutely packed during Mass and the…
We Made the Phila Inquirer!
Certainly not the first time we've made it into a major newspaper. God smiles on us."Carnival Draws a Crowd in…

Email Signup

Sign up for daily email updates about the campaign.

Enter your email address:

Facebook

Twitter: Savestmarys

Confidential Tip Line

We would like to announce our totally confidential tip line, for anyone with information pertaining to St. Mary's or their own parish, dealings with the diocese, etc. Remember, you need not give your name, or you may if you choose to. Contact us by email: info@savestmarys.net or phone: 856-692-0222 (ask for Leah).