We've received so many tips lately on savestmarys. Thank you to one and all, there is so much to do and we are continually heartened by the broad level of input and participation on the part of those in and out of the diocese. This most recent article was forwarded to us since it is so very valid in this and other diocese and truly epitomizes the crisis in the Church at this time. It is very interesting and disturbing.
These Forty Years of Loyalty and
Dissent: Humanae Vitae on the 40th Anniversary
I regret to have been surprised with the fortieth anniversary of Humanae Vitae
just two days after my return from World Youth Day 2008 in Sydney Australia.
I regret it, because it is a huge piece of what is happening in the Church
and the world today, and I did not have time to prepare some commentary.
I cannot praise enough, nor recommend enough, Cardinal Stafford's laudable
narration of his experiences and insights (cf. Humanae
Vitae: The Year of the Peirasmòs -- 1968, By Cardinal James Francis Stafford).
If only the whole Church were full of such pastors: wise insight into their
pastoral experiences, cultured in their literary background, faithful to the
Magisterium, and charitable in their assessments.
After my mind was blown away by the frankness and depth of his article, one
aspect has struck me, even though it is an accidental point his article made.
And it is this impression upon which I want to compound. It has to do with
the unity, charity and brotherhood of the diocesan priesthood. Or better said,
the complete lack thereof in our day. I think Cardinal Stafford does well to
expose the causes.
My experience with clergy at every level of government of the Church is full
of very unpleasant memories, and requires on my part a continual effort for
forgiveness. And I forgive, as I need God to forgive me. Where I should have
expected kindness, support, brotherhood, acceptance, advice and even
fraternal correction, I have experienced every form of anger, lies and
gossip, attack of my good name, varying degrees of hatred, exclusion,
rejection and uncharitable criticism.
Did I merit such conduct, I must ask myself with all honesty? I think the
answer is no, I did not. The hostility has come from heretics and liturgical
abusers, and from a group of men who have done all to cherish one another,
and defend each others' conduct which includes everything from impurity to
abuse of alcohol to an absolute absence of a life of prayer to abuse of money
to... well, we've all seen it in public and in private. But to this one could
say, "That is an attack ad hominem,
and proves nothing." OK, I agree.
Yet the reasons for this hostile conduct have been because: I refused to
abuse the liturgy, I stood in the way of the Precious Body and Blood being
washed down the drain, I preferred gold to glass for the species at Mass, I
wanted to hear confessions every day before Mass, I adhered to a religious
orders' Constitutions to the point of earning the contempt of my superiors,
and I refused to say mass on a dirty coffee table in a living room. I earned
ridicule because I pray the breviary every day (an obligation for priests
under pain of mortal sin), because I employ Latin whenever possible in the
liturgy, because I get up very early and because I don't watch TV. And after
four years of the priesthood, I'm in my ninth parish, when each removal was a
completely unilateral decision on the part of pastors, to whom I showed
charity in exchange for their abuse. I could go on and on, but I think that's
enough to make the point: If I were punished for evil deeds, I would deserve
it. But the abuse comes from loyalty to the Catholic Church, in teaching and
in practice.
A good priest friend of mine made an excellent observation a couple months
ago: the first of all religious orders is the diocesan priesthood. It is
truly a community, a brotherhood, or at least should be. Yet ever since the
1700's (I think of the rise of Illuminism, Freemasonry, St. Clement Mary
Hofbauer, etc.), there has been an increasing decline in the unity among the
clergy, and it is not rare to find in recent and late history true
persecution of faithful clergy by unfaithful clergy.
Allow me to be clear: The problem is dissent. And dissent is a fruit of sin.
Cardinal Stafford mentions how the annihilation of fraternity among today's
clergy returns especially to those priests, older now, who have rejected Humanae Vitae. He says, "The
Archdiocesan priesthood lost something of the fraternal whole which Baltimore
priests had known for generations."
The persistence of this dissent has not fizzled away, as he says, "Contempt
for the truth, whether aggressive or passive, has become common in Church
life. Dissenting priests, theologians and laypeople have continued their
coercive techniques." The coercion takes the form of the mentality of
"dissent with us or we'll treat you worse than the trash," accompanied by
group enterprises in which dissenters would rope in faithful priests against
their will, and then give them no voice. This is why the Cardinal says, "No
dialogue was possible in 1968; it remained impossible in 1978. There was no
common ground." And there still is none. "Diocesan presbyterates have not
recovered from the July/August nights in 1968."
I regularly avoid priest meetings in my local area. I have sat in on many,
and have found that they are places where bad priests gossip and slander good
priests, where the spirit of dissent is cultivated by discussions about how
to get rid of the all-male clergy, the celibate clergy and how to justify
homosexual conduct. When schools close by the handful, I have seen the clergy
wrangling over "who gets the money" while no one even attempts to discuss
"how are we going to educate our community's children in the Catholic
faith?". I have sat in on meetings of ministry and apostolate where the
discussion was all about numbers and money, and apostles lower on the power
ladder would position themselves again and again to climb that very ladder.
There is not rarely excessive drinking, criticism of Rome
and of the Pope, a total hatred of Catholic forms of piety and devotion,
contempt for rubrics. Childish fighting, childish conduct, childish
discussion and immature faith.
If I had the Catholic faith in common with my brother priests, I'd probably
be criticized by my parishioners for neglecting them and spending so much
time among such exemplary men. But we do not have the Catholic faith in
common. I have little in common, in fact, with heretics, dissenters and
haters of Rome ,
or with those who are apostles of sin.
I have no experience of a true fraternity of priests in a presbyterate or
religious order; at least Cardinal Stafford new the day when he was a younger
priest. Somehow in the back of my head, I can imagine what that might be
like. Sure, there would be the occasional challenge of getting along with
someone because of personality conflicts or minor defects; that's to be
expected even in families. No, I'm not crying about my situation, just
explaining why I don't go to all these gatherings of priests, and expressing
a hope for reform in the Church.
Fortunately in my parish, there are two other diocesan priests, Fr.
Bustamante and Fr. Perrone, and an occasionally varying collection of
exemplary priests from the Canons Regular of the Holy Cross. We do form a
sort of community, we discuss spiritual matters and encourage one another to
be faithful. We share discoveries about the ancient liturgy, the Pope's
latest teachings, the good example of the saints. And all that with lots of
humor besides. We even do sports together and share meals.
Many faithful priests in the world are isolated by the type of coercion which
the Cardinal mentioned. I meet them everywhere, including priests from around
the world at World Youth Day, and many tell the same stories: abuse in
exchange for fidelity. Yes, there are good priests out there; one Australian article stresses that there are many in
fact. But dissenters in powerful positions put these faithful priests in very
difficult positions and places, and places far from other faithful priests.
It is not good for man to be alone, and every priest needs a presbyterate of
brothers with whom to encourage, commiserate, bless, advise, laugh and pursue
holiness.
May it please the Lord to send a great reformer to the Church. And may
Catholic priests one day discover that they do, indeed, have Catholicism in
common.
Fr. Paul Ward