Author Michael Rose on St. Mary's Seminary gay subculture

Comments (4)
For link click here (transcripts to the show)

Here's a snippet for ya, from Alan Keyes show on June 13, 2002:

We have with us tonight the author of a book, "Goodbye, Good Men: How Liberals Brought Corruption into the Catholic Church." Michael Rose is somebody who hasn't shrunk from looking at this aspect of the issue head-on, going into whether there is in fact a factual basis for this concern about tolerance for homosexuality within the priesthood and it's effects.

Michael Rose, welcome to MAKING SENSE.

MICHAEL ROSE, AUTHOR: Thank you so much, Alan. Thanks for having me on.

KEYES: Now, obviously you have thought about this very question, in terms of the contribution made by homosexuality to this crisis and the role that it played. What would you say is, in fact, the role of homosexuality? Is it a root cause here? Is it a symptom, in terms of the kind of problems that have emerged over the course of the last months and years?

ROSE: Well, I think the problem really is the gay subculture that has flourished in the seminaries over the last 35 years. And in my research, one of the obstacles to young men becoming priests in the Catholic Church has been the presence of that active gay subculture.

Often a young man will enter a Catholic seminary expecting to find wise, strong men, like Bing Crosby or Spencer Tracy. And what he finds instead sometimes are the Village People. At St. Mary's in Baltimore, for example, there were many students who recounted to me seeing fellow students and also faculty members actually gathering together to go cruise the gay bars on the weekend.

And if that wasn't bad enough, when the students complained about the gay subculture, oftentimes they were persecuted. They were sent to psychological counseling for being homophobic. They were labeled sexually disordered, and eventually expunged from the system.


(CROSSTALK)

KEYES: Go ahead. I didn't mean to interrupt.

ROSE: Well, I was just going to add that what I found in my research, interviewing over 150 men who were in the seminaries, is that there's been sort of a reverse discrimination. There's been a systematic rooting out of the man who accepts the teachings of the Catholic Church, and especially the teachings on sexual morality. And I'm talking over the last three decades, or so.




4 Comments

Anonymous on May 29, 2008 8:24 AM

My understanding is that this seminary in Baltimore is now the seminary of choice for the Diocese of Camden under the leadership of Bishop Galante. Doesn't inspire confidence in his vision for the Diocese of Camden.

St. Marys Author Profile Page on May 29, 2008 9:29 AM

No indeed it does not. One has to wonder about bishop's motivations in switching seminaries. A contact informed me that it was due to Galante's "theological differences" with St. Charles Borromeo. Additionally, Bishop Galante will not allow the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter, which has allegedly offered to send us priests since they are bursting at the seams.

Donna Noble on June 5, 2008 10:30 PM

I must question the truth regarding the statement about the Baltimore Seminary being the "seminary of choice" for Bishop Galante.

***

Editor's Note: We do not accept posts from double identities. This "sanpietro98" posing under a second identity. For the curious, "Donna Noble" is a Dr. Who character. Cute. Clearly this "person" is representing the diocese in some fashion and this website is not intended to give the diocese a platform to spew its propaganda.

Anonymous on June 6, 2008 9:39 AM

Well Donna, send us the data that shows otherwise, like a list of seminarians that have entered seminary under Galante's reign, the date they entered, and where they've gone and it should become clear rather quickly.

I'd love to believe that this isn't true, so please, convince us!

Why Save St. Mary's?

What's true for OL Queen of Peace, Pitman & Assumption, Wildwood Crest is also true for St. Mary's Malaga:

"The people in Pitman bought that ground and built that church and it belongs to them. You can't just take it away."

-Anthony Mecca, Queen of Peace Parish, Pitman (also on the slate for closure), May 8, 2008

"This is God's house. Let us live here with God as we've done all these years."

-Fred Spiewak, Assumption Parish, Wildwood Crest, June 11, 2008

Frequently Asked Questions

Full list of Frequently Asked Questions about the Church Closings

Recent Entries

Jim Walsh of the Courier Post Puckers Up Again: Profile of a Texas McChurch
The problem is that Megachurches promote and empty, consumerist spirituality that leaves no room for self-reflection. Or that's what they…
St. Anthony's Hammonton
Here's a link to the "Hammonton News" piece that describes how happy and relieved the St. Anthony's parishioners are (I'm…
Fr. Gregorio Letter to the Editor
This letter to the editor was in the Cape May County Herald a month ago, in direct response to the…

Email Signup

Sign up for daily email updates about the campaign.

Enter your email address:

Confidential Tip Line

We would like to announce our totally confidential tip line, for anyone with information pertaining to St. Mary's or their own parish, dealings with the diocese, etc. Remember, you need not give your name, or you may if you choose to. Contact us by email: info@savestmarys.net or phone: 856-692-0222 (ask for Leah).